Sun News and New Prosperity Mine
Some of you may remember the report I wrote this past summer describing the debate over the New Prosperity Mine application in Williams Lake. I attended a few debates over the mine with my mother-in-law and there was a very strong division in the room. Supporters of the mine wore blue scarves, were primarily white, and mostly discussed the economic benefits. Most of the individuals speaking out against the mine were from the reserves surrounding the mining area, where they would be most closely affected.
There were also several very detailed environmental reports brought forward after the general public discussion. While I wasn’t able to make every one due to work, I was able to sit in on a report by a grizzly bear specialist. They shared exactly how the mine project would harm the already threatened grizzly bear community in the area. Again, that was only one one of many other extensive environmental reports.
It was a huge surprise for me when I heard that the project was rejected. It was surprising because we all know, primarily from the Enbridge pipeline debate, that the Canadian government is usually quite happy to ignore indigenous and environmental outcry over projects that will bring a monetary benefit.
At this point you may wonder what this has to do with Sun News, and I should probably share that this Shame Day was initially prompted by Ezra Levant’s rant about the rejection of the mine. Unfortunately I can’t embed the video so you will have to click here.
Obviously I’m biased in my opinion on this project, but in the report I shared with you this summer even I tried to represent both sides. In his rant, Levant, in contrast, tries to draw attention away from the legitimate concerns surrounding the mine by focusing on details that better support his opinion: that it would be “the best thing ever to happen to a very poor part of Canada.” I’m not saying there aren’t two sides to the argument, and I fully acknowledge that a large part of the William’s Lake community probably agrees with Levant, but he intentionally strives to downplay anything that goes against his argument. The lake that is threatened by the mine, a lake with spiritual and cultural significance to surrounding First Nations communities, Levant reduces to “a few fishing holes”. Levant also ignores the environmental report that the mine would threaten grizzly bears and instead focuses on how it would affect moose, which he calls “pests”.
So it’s a red herring. He has some legitimate arguments, but he attempts to downplay or ignore any legitimate arguments that don’t coincide with his own. Does this kind of news broadcasting sound familiar?
Sun News vs. The CBC
I guess you won’t be surprised then when I tell you how Sun News has been called “Fox News North” by Canadians who aren’t overly fond of having a news station that pushes a far Right agenda. This includes our very own political poet, Margaret Atwood, who was quoted saying “[Sun News is] part of the ‘I make the rules around here,’ Harper-is-a-king thing.”
Like Fox, Sun News gushes with over the top patriotism. Like Fox, Sun News has also been accused of using “hot chicks and sexy outfits” to help sell sub-par news coverage.
What really gets my goat, however, is the way they’ve been trying to attack the CBC, the government subsidized channel. Before my dear American friends get to thinking “state interference = bad” then let me reassure you that, generally speaking, we love the CBC. It’s by far the best place to hear news relevant to Canadians, since American-owned companies very easily flood all our other sources with American news.
CBC News, unlike Sun, avoids commentary and strives to present balanced news as best as they can. Many private news industries are influenced by their private sponsors, which isn’t a problem with the CBC. Even the the Canadian government gets a slap on the wrist when they try to interfere with them, since they’re run by an autonomous board of directors. So what does Sun News think we should do with the CBC? Well, privatize it of course.
How does the rest of Canada feel about it? Are we tired of our tax dollars going to support a media giant who is untainted by government control or private sponsors?
And how do Canadians feel about Sun News comparatively?
And while we’re at it, let’s just ask ourselves, why does Sun News want the CBC to privatize? Well, probably because they are owned by QMI. While I really don’t have time to get into QMI or media concentration right now, I wanted to point out how much of our media (including various news sources) they already own.
Sun News and Muslims
How else is Sun News like Fox? Well, the staff at Sun News sure don’t believe in being stifled by politically correct liberals. That’s probably why Ezra Levant is currently being being sued for libel after calling Muslim lawyer Khurrum Awan a “money grubbing […] liar”. In other news, he has also called Iran a “hell hole” and the niqab a “body bag”. Many media sources are currently championing Levant’s case as a fight for free speech. Heck, even Rick Mercer has defended Levant’s rights to freedom of speech at one point:
Unfortunately, this isn’t even the first time Sun News has targeted the Muslim community with their “Straight Talk”. After the Boston Bombing, Michael Coren told his Sun News audience that they really should have expected the bomber to be Muslim since (according to him) Muslims commit the most terrorist attacks in the States.
Let me give some context to his claim since, you know, I’m a liberal aristocrat and all:
Honestly, I think this post has gone on long enough. Also, I’m tired of watching Straight Talk videos that make me want to punch a wall. So I’m going to leave you with this tid-bit from Rob Ford’s segment on Sun News. It’s such riveting entertainment even Sun News couldn’t handle it.
P.S. If you have a spare moment, you may want to check out VICE’s documentary on the Rob Ford scandal and how commentary journalism (like what we see at F and Sun) has promoted the idea that all journalism is a scam. For example, half the city of Toronto assumed that The Toronto Star was lying about Rob Ford smoking crack.