So right off the bat, I want to say that Arthur Chu of Jeopardy-winning fame has already done much of the groundwork for me with his [spoiler-filled] article “Not Your Asian Ninja: How the Marvel Cinematic Universe Keeps Failing Asian-Americans“. In it he recounts his primary disappointment with the second season of Netflix’s Daredevil, namely that the Asians presented in that show are generally villains across the board.
Not only are they of an evil persuasion, they’re also, as the title of his piece implies, mostly ninjas. In terms of sheer volume the vast majority of Asians seen on screen during the season’s 13 episodes are that particular brand of martial artist. The rest are, in terms of representation, gangsters, white collar criminals, and crime lords. It is, as Chu says, “Not a good look.”
He picks the Kitchen Irish, a gang of an obvious ethnic background, as his primary example of the show using nuance with a people group. Matthew Murdock, the titular crimefighter himself, is of Irish descent, and another character nicknamed “Grotto” is a former member of the mob who elicits sympathy from both the show’s cast and its audience. While I understand that Irish heritage is unique and distinct from many others, and that people of Irish descent suffered extreme racism in early American history, what shouldn’t be ignored is the fact that on the surface they are White. As are the members of fellow gang the Dogs of Hell. As are Murdock’s friends Karen Page and Foggy Nelson. As is Frank Castle, the Punisher, as well as newspaper editor Mitchell Ellison. Television is full of White people, and with Daredevil being no exception simply stating that there are varied roles within even one subgroup feels like a given.
Unfortunately, Asians fail even when stacked up against other racial minorities. Continue reading
Posted in Asia, comics, crime, race, television, writing
Tagged Arthur Chu, asian, black, Daniel Yang, Daredevil, Dilton, inscrubtable, irish, martial arts, netflix, Ninja, race, racism, Reggie, representation, Riverdale, Ross Butler, stereotype, token, villain, white
Early this week I was perusing Marvel’s solicitations for May 2013, and came across the following cover for Avengers #11:
Art by Dustin Weaver.
The first part of the issue’s description [and the one I thought was most relevant] was the following:
As Shang-Chi battles an ancient enemy, the Avengers hang out in Hong Kong’s swankiest casino. Continue reading
Posted in art, Asia, bizarreness, comics, internet, race, writing
Tagged #11, Adi Tantimedh, anime, Asia, asian, avengers, Black Widow, Bleeding Cool, can't tell the difference, Cannonball, Captain Marvel, China, comic books, comics, cover, Deodato, disappointing, Dustin Weaver, Ghost In The Shell, Hickman, Hong Kong, indistinguishable, Japan, Japanese Culture, Jet Jaguar, Jonathan Hickman, lazy, Major Kusanagi, Marvel, Ninja, r/comics, race, racism, reddit, representation, Samurai, schoolgirl outfit, Shang-Chi, Spider-Woman, stereotypes, Sunspot, The Outhouse, Tokyo
EVAN: Ladies and gentlemen, boys and girls, welcome to the first installment of E> where Gordon and I try to uncover the magic that was lost. The last post we did fell a little flat, so we’re here to casually discuss a subject we both know is awesome: DEADLIEST WARRIOR.
GORDON: That’s right- Deadliest Warrior, a show 90% about mutilating ballistic gel dummies, and it was STILL too intellectual for Spike. At least, that’s my version of why they cancelled it. You can probably tell we’re a little bit bitter about the whole thing.
EVAN: Ugh, Spike. Have you seen the little bits of footage they slot in between shows to fill up the space?
GORDON: I have not.
EVAN: It’s like . . . Here, let me find one.
Readers, the following is kinda PG-13. I kind of apologize for embedding this, but it’s just too ridiculous not to:
Posted in Evan and Gordon Talk, race, television
Tagged Arab, Deadliest Warrior, Discovery Channel, Emperor Qin, Evan and Gordon Talk, flamethrower, History Channel, improvements, IRA, Lawrence of Arabia, Ming Warrior, Ninja, Persian Immortal, Rajput Warrior, Roman Centurion, Saladin, Samurai, Season 3, Spartan, Spike TV, Sun Tzu, Taliban, television, TV, vampires, Viking, weapons, zombies